Hero Background
Door Deal vs Guarantee: Which One Actually Pays (and When a Versus Deal Wins)

Door Deal vs Guarantee: Which One Actually Pays (and When a Versus Deal Wins)

Published on November 6, 2026

You got an offer. Somebody typed "door" or "guarantee" or "$300 vs 80" into an email like it's obvious. It isn't. Those few words decide who eats a dead Tuesday, who keeps the money when the room is packed, and whether your band drives home with gas money or with a new credit card balance.

This one is for before you say yes. We'll map the three deal shapes, the gross-vs-net trap, break-even tickets, a side-by-side example of the same night under three offers, and what to get in writing. Then you punch your own numbers into a free calculator. No signup, no sales call.

(Already played and staring at the envelope? That's a different fight: how to split gig money in a band.)

The three deal structures (and what they actually mean)

Every offer is really a question: who carries the risk that nobody shows up? Each structure answers it differently.

Guarantee: a fixed fee, rain or shine

A guarantee (sometimes called a flat fee) means you get a set amount whether 10 people show up or 200. The venue or promoter carries more of the attendance risk. The trade-off: your upside is capped. If you sell out, the extra ticket money goes to them, unless the deal also includes a backend (a bonus or percentage past a certain point).

Good for: knowing what you'll make before you leave home.

Door deal: a cut of the tickets, no floor

A door deal (door split) pays you a percentage of ticket money. Big night, big payout. Empty room, tiny payout, and there's no floor unless the deal is a hybrid. You're carrying the attendance risk.

The one question you always ask: "Percentage of what?" Of gross ticket sales? Or of what's left after the venue takes out its costs? Industry writeups on door deals keep hammering this point for a reason. Same percentage, very different money. More on that below.

Versus deal: whichever is higher, not both

A versus deal, written like "$300 vs 80% of net," means you get the guarantee or the percentage, whichever is higher. You don't get both added together. That's the most common misunderstanding about versus deals, and it's an expensive one to discover at settlement.

Versus deals often come with a threshold (sometimes called the nut): costs the promoter recovers before the percentage kicks in. So the percentage side only beats the guarantee once the room does well enough to clear that threshold and outrun your floor.

Good for: a floor that protects you on a slow night, plus upside if you pack it.

Gross door vs net door: the quiet money killer

"80/20" sounds generous. It might be. It depends entirely on what number the 80 comes from.

EXAMPLE (made-up numbers, not a market average):

  • Ticket sales (gross): $2,000
  • Venue expenses taken out first (sound, door person, etc.): $800
  • 80% of gross: $2,000 × 0.80 = $1,600 to the band
  • 80% of net: ($2,000 − $800) × 0.80 = $960 to the band

Same "80/20." Same crowd. $640 apart. That's a van repair. That's a tank of gas to every show for a while.

Net deals aren't automatically a scam. Rooms have real costs. But you should know which deal you're in before you play, and you should know what's coming out. Ask:

  • Which expenses come out before our percentage? Get the list.
  • Is there a cap on expenses? "Up to $X" beats "whatever it ends up being."
  • Can we see an itemized settlement? A reasonable promoter can show you the math.
  • Are ticketing / card fees taken out before the split?
  • Do comps and guest list count? (They don't pay, so they don't put money in your percentage.)

Who should take which deal?

There's no universal "best" structure. Anyone who tells you one deal type is always right is selling something. Here's a rough band-side map, not a rulebook:

Lean guarantee when: - Your overhead is real: long drive, lodging, a hired fill-in or sound person. - You don't know your draw in that city. Your hometown crowd doesn't follow you three hours away. - It's a weeknight, a new room, or a bill you didn't build.

Lean door when: - You've proven your draw there, recently, with paying people (not a pile of "interested" clicks). - The ticket price and room size can actually pay you at a realistic turnout. - The deductions are written down, and you're fine with them.

Push for a versus when: - You've got some leverage (a draw, a good bill, a history with the room) and want a floor and upside. - The promoter wants to pay door but you've got real travel costs to protect.

And when two offers come in with totally different shapes, don't eyeball it. Get them to the same number. Which brings us to...

Break-even tickets: the one number that makes offers comparable

A guarantee is a number. A door deal is a formula. You can't compare a number to a formula by vibes. You need the break-even paid attendance: how many paying people have to walk in for this deal to cover your costs.

For a door deal, the band-side rough version is:

Break-even tickets ≈ your costs ÷ (ticket price × your door %)

That's the same basic method a lot of break-even tools and promoter models use, just pointed at your side of the table. Then ask the gut-check question: is that number realistic for us, in this room, on this night? If you'd need 80 paid to break even and your last show there pulled 25, you know what to do.

Two reminders:

  • Paying fans, not guest list. Your partner, the openers' roommates and the sound guy's cousin don't move the door.
  • Our free Gig Profit Calculator spits out break-even paid attendance for you. Heads-up: break-even there holds guarantee, merch and costs fixed, so it answers "how many tickets with everything else as typed."

Worked EXAMPLE: same night, three offers

Everything below is EXAMPLE / made-up numbers. Not typical pay, not a benchmark. Swap in your own.

The setup (EXAMPLE): - 150-cap room, $15 tickets - Your band's costs for the night: $300 (gas, a cheap motel, food) - Three offers on the table: 1. Offer A — Guarantee: $400 flat 2. Offer B — Door: 70% of gross ticket sales 3. Offer C — Versus: $300 vs 80% of net, where net = gross minus $600 venue expenses

What the band receives (EXAMPLE):

Paid attendance Gross door A: $400 guarantee B: 70% of gross C: $300 vs 80% of net
30 (rough night) $450 $400 $315 $300 (floor wins; net is $0)
60 (expected) $900 $400 $630 $300 (80% of $300 = $240, floor wins)
100 (great night) $1,500 $400 $1,050 $720 (80% of $900 beats floor)

After the band's $300 in costs (EXAMPLE):

Paid attendance A B C
30 +$100 +$15 $0
60 +$100 +$330 $0
100 +$100 +$750 +$420

What this made-up night tells you:

  • Offer A is the "sleep at night" pick. You never lose, you never win big.
  • Offer B breaks even at about 29 paid ($300 ÷ ($15 × 0.70) ≈ 28.6). Past that, every ticket is yours to keep. If you honestly expect 60, B is the better deal here, and it's not close.
  • Offer C sounds like the best of both worlds, but with a $600 expense nut the percentage side doesn't beat the $300 floor until around 66 paid. Below that it's basically a $300 guarantee. A versus is only as good as its threshold.

Notice the "best" offer flips depending on turnout. That's the whole game: be honest about your draw, then pick.

Run yours: punch both offers into the free Gig Profit Calculator. No signup, and nothing you type leaves the page.

How to run a versus deal in the calculator (honest version)

The calculator has fields for a guarantee and a door split, and if you fill in both, it adds them together. That's right for a "guarantee plus door" deal, but wrong for a versus deal. There's no special versus button. So:

  1. Run it once with only the guarantee (door split at 0).
  2. Run it again with only the door % (guarantee at 0). If it's a net deal, lower the expected door to reflect what's left after the venue's expenses, or account for it however your deal is written.
  3. Take the higher net. That's your versus result.

Two runs, thirty seconds, no surprises at 1 AM.

What to get in writing before you load in

A handshake and a text that says "door deal cool?" isn't a deal. Before the show, get a short deal memo (an email works) covering:

  • Structure: guarantee, door %, or versus
  • The percentage, and whether it's of gross or net
  • Deductible expenses: the actual list, plus a cap if there is one
  • Versus threshold / nut, if it's a versus deal
  • Ticket prices (advance and day-of) and how comps are handled
  • Merch: does the venue take a cut? What percentage?
  • Payment: when, how (cash, check, transfer), and who signs off on settlement
  • Who else is on the bill and how the door is divided between bands

Guidance from musician organizations like the UK Musicians' Union points the same way: get deductions spelled out before you accept. That's guidance, not law where you live, but it's good advice anywhere.

After the money lands

Once the promoter hands over the envelope, the job changes: costs come off, whoever fronted gas gets paid back, the band fund gets its slice, then everybody gets their cut. We wrote the whole playbook (plus a copy-paste money agreement for the group chat) here: How to Split Gig Money in a Band Without Starting a War.

Not sure the gig is worth booking at all? Start one step earlier: Will my gig make money?

FAQ

What is a door deal vs a guarantee? A guarantee is a fixed fee no matter the turnout. A door deal is a percentage of ticket money, so your pay rises and falls with attendance. With a guarantee the venue carries more risk; with a door deal you do.

What is a versus deal? Do I get both? No. A versus deal ("guarantee vs percentage") pays whichever is higher, the guarantee or your percentage, not both added together.

What does "80/20" mean, and of gross or net? It usually means 80% to the band and 20% to the venue. Whether that's of gross ticket sales or of net (after the venue's expenses) depends on the deal. Ask, and get it in writing.

When is a door deal smarter than a guarantee for a DIY band? When you've got a proven, recent paying draw in that specific room or city, the ticket price can pay you at a realistic turnout, and the deductions are written down. If your draw there is a guess, a guarantee is usually the safer bet.

How do I compare two offers with different shapes? Convert both to the same number: what the band nets at a realistic attendance, plus the break-even paid attendance for each. A low / expected / high turnout table (like the example above) makes the trade-off obvious.

How do I work out break-even attendance for my costs? Roughly, your total costs divided by what you earn per paid ticket (ticket price × your door %, adjusted if it's a net deal). The free Gig Profit Calculator shows break-even paid attendance for you.

What expenses can the venue take out before my percentage? Whatever your deal says, which is exactly why you should ask for the list and a cap before you agree. Common items to ask about: sound, door staff, ticketing or card fees. Ask for an itemized settlement.

How do I model a versus deal in the Sonic DIY calculator? Run it twice: once with only the guarantee, once with only the door split. Take the higher net. If you enter both, the calculator adds them, which is right for "guarantee plus door" but not for a versus deal.

Should merch be in the door math? Keep it separate. Merch is your money (minus what the stock cost you and any venue merch cut), not ticket money. The calculator has its own fields for merch sales and merch cost. Ask the venue about merch cuts up front.

Is any deal type "standard"? No. Deal terms vary by room, city, promoter and bill. Don't let anyone tell you a term is "standard" as a reason to accept it. Compare it to your own numbers.

Run the numbers before you say yes

You don't need a manager or a spreadsheet degree. You need ten minutes and your real costs.

Open the free Gig Profit Calculator → Punch in both offers. For a versus deal, run guarantee-only, then door-only, and take the higher net. No signup, and it's a planning estimate, not a promise of what you'll get paid.

Want to keep the gig and the deal terms somewhere the whole band can see? You can set up a free band workspace. Totally optional; the calculator works without it.




Category: Money & Gigs

Tags: door deal , guarantee , versus deal , break-even , booking

Sonic DIY
Find us